This microforum brought to you
by the principle of
TRANSPARENCY

Forum 113 Anarcho-Leninist Debate on State--Comments on Part 3
Comments on Part 3

all posts for
this forum are
on this page
-- page 730 --
Click the vote button to vote for posts that you consider informed or thoughtful. Posts with the most votes will be put on the best page.
IMPORTANT: You can vote for as many different commentss as you want, but please,
DON'T try to stack the vote by voting multiple times for the same comments.

good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:07 pm # 113-7335
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:06 pm # 113-7334
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:05 pm # 113-7333
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:04 pm # 113-7332
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:02 pm # 113-7331
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 2-Aug-2009 • 10:01 pm # 113-7330
HIYAqONmvRuYHAG xOrmxGuLspExF
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 18-Jul-2009 • 3:27 pm # 113-7329
NbuskEFB kRnbiReswaS
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 18-Jul-2009 • 3:26 pm # 113-7328
NbuskEFB kRnbiReswaS
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 18-Jul-2009 • 3:26 pm # 113-7327
NbuskEFB kRnbiReswaS
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 14-Jun-2009 • 10:16 am # 113-7326
GbNwaNcOvKYOMvr MzJPUlmxE
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 14-Jun-2009 • 10:15 am # 113-7325
GbNwaNcOvKYOMvr MzJPUlmxE
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Wednesday • 10-Jun-2009 • 4:31 pm # 113-7324
KluXoJJJBMwyw rMzYBGpGPmU
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Wednesday • 10-Jun-2009 • 4:30 pm # 113-7323
KluXoJJJBMwyw rMzYBGpGPmU
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Wednesday • 10-Jun-2009 • 4:30 pm # 113-7322
KluXoJJJBMwyw rMzYBGpGPmU
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 23-May-2009 • 11:41 am # 113-7321
vPzLoAoVN cMGTnhLcdXmiABgV
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 23-May-2009 • 11:40 am # 113-7320
vPzLoAoVN cMGTnhLcdXmiABgV
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 23-May-2009 • 11:39 am # 113-7319
vPzLoAoVN cMGTnhLcdXmiABgV
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 28-Feb-2009 • 4:38 am # 113-7318
LRShBgUiP uGkkvfXkofxe
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 14-Feb-2009 • 2:32 pm # 113-7317
ZPlrSGgBwjwJGo IqKlLxsTMVKj
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? not sure
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? No--Ben's points are irrelevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 14-Feb-2009 • 9:37 am # 113-7316
BugJtMoEQNjWJ WMyodmdMYzsNFDDXZZh
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Saturday • 24-Jan-2009 • 2:52 am # 113-7315
DBLueVlwV njnyYpLj
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 4-Jan-2009 • 8:17 am # 113-7314
CAMsyufAaMObUze twGCwWmNYRk
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 4-Jan-2009 • 8:15 am # 113-7313
CAMsyufAaMObUze twGCwWmNYRk
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 4-Jan-2009 • 8:13 am # 113-7312
CAMsyufAaMObUze twGCwWmNYRk
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? not sure
good comments

comment on part 3 Thursday • 28-Feb-2008 • 4:04 pm # 113-7311
lEvQLPVR LnepvMCHpCM
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? not sure
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Tuesday • 2-Oct-2007 • 9:59 pm # 113-7310
t198t t198t
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? Yes--Ben has represented Daniel's views fairly
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? Yes--Ben answered all of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? No--heard it all before
good comments

comment on part 3 Tuesday • 2-Oct-2007 • 11:58 am # 113-7309
t59t t59t
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? Yes--Ben has represented Daniel's views fairly
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? Yes--Ben answered all of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? No--heard it all before
good comments

comment on part 3 Wednesday • 26-Sep-2007 • 10:50 am # 113-7308
t504t t504t
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? Yes--Ben has represented Daniel's views fairly
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? Yes--Ben answered all of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? No--heard it all before
good comments

comment on part 3 Monday • 4-Dec-2006 • 4:16 am # 113-7307
Radagast2072 A point which should be added is that, in the face of Bourgeois attempted decapitation and coup attempts, the workers will have to form their own wide-based, democratically-controlled militia to defend themselves against Bourgeois and Fascist violence
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? Yes--Ben has represented Daniel's views fairly
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? Yes--Ben answered all of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Monday • 7-Feb-2005 • 9:13 am # 113-7306
Daniel Ben does not address the fundamental truism I highlighted about human nature, which I explained/made insightful comments on probably better than previous examples. What makes you think that this digital media fire will be attractive to people, will Americans really want to watch it? Won't they see it as simply dangerous and evil communist propaganda?
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? No--Ben has distorted Daniel's views
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? No--Ben evaded some of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? not sure
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 22-Dec-2002 • 10:25 pm # 113-7305
nihilix well, i think there needs to be a red-black-green synthisys of ideas to really kick ass, and you've not got it so far. i like the iww, i like what judy bari did there. but my red-green-black is about white radical politix; what does the South think?
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? other
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? other
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Friday • 20-Dec-2002 • 12:37 am # 113-7304
Your dynamic is doomed to failure because of the enemy creates nd the fact that it is ripe for corruption
good comments

comment on part 3 Wednesday • 13-Nov-2002 • 1:35 am # 113-7303
fuzzbox A question for Ben. When you lay out the steps, you talk about preventing the bourgeoisie from using their property to influence public opinion. You call this "enforcing the seperation of speech and property". What I don't understand is why the expropriations -- full on -- don't take place first thing. Then you don't have to worry about the "flight of capital" or the "sepration of speech and property"... I mean if you think that it would be too problematic to immediately seize the ill-gotten, bourgeois wealth, don't you think it will be just as to much trouble to "enforce" this seperation?
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? other
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? other
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 13-Oct-2002 • 5:47 pm # 113-7302
Prole Katt As a radical unionist (I'm really a an anarcho/syndicalist/communist, but I try to tone it down for my wife's sake) I am enjoying the hell out of this!!
good comments

comment on part 3 Sunday • 13-Oct-2002 • 12:15 am # 113-7301
test guy this is a test of the MicroForum for part 3 of the debate
poll response:
polemical decency Has Ben exercized great care to fairly characterize Daniel's positions and arguments? Yes--Ben has represented Daniel's views fairly
non-evasive Has Ben answered all questions that Daniel has asked? Yes--Ben answered all of Daniel's questions
relevant Are the points that Ben raises relevant to the debate question? Yes--Ben's points are relevant to the debate question
insightful Has Ben raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points? Yes--interesting and insightful

all posts for
this forum are
on this page
-- page 730 --
Click the vote button to vote for posts that you consider informed or thoughtful. Posts with the most votes will be put on the best page.
IMPORTANT: You can vote for as many different commentss as you want, but please,
DON'T try to stack the vote by voting multiple times for the same comments.

This microforum has been brought to you
by the principle of
TRANSPARENCY

Interactivity for this site
by the Red Team


Information refineries
for the proletarian century