Frequently Asked Questions
What is communism? • What is socialism? • What happened to Lenin's 1917 revolution? • What democratic rights will workers have after the overthrow of bourgeois rule? • How will workers prevent the former bourgeoisie (or a new ruling class) from coming back to power? • What will a genuine classless, communist society be like?
How will economics, politics and culture work
when the working class runs modern society?
Working class rule has never existed in a modern, stable society. However it will emerge triumphant in the 21st century. How will a workers' state suppress the former ruling bourgeoisie without also suppressing the independent political life of workers?

comments on communism

To see previous responses, click here.
Click the button in the green box to vote for a post. The posts with the most votes will be put on the best posts and top 10 pages. You can vote for as many different posts as you want, but please, don't vote multiple times for the same post.

 
Keepin it Capitalist for me.
Friday • 13-Sep-2002 • 3:27 pm • # 2050 • 75-25R-SW
James • Reno, USA • 17 • student / welder •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byother
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
I think that communism is not a good form of government and personaly I would never want to live under a communist rule. If other people in the world want to be equal to everyone else and not try to survive in a real world where you have to work for what you get than go ahead but don't bother other non-communist countries that would like to have a challange in life.
 
Long live socialism!
Friday • 13-Sep-2002 • 2:28 pm • # 2049 • 72-48P-ZW
Erik • Sandefjord, Norway • 19 • Student • http://kommunisme.no
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
It's good to see communists from all over the world here. The popularity of socialism/communism has been at a very low point the last few years, but we're on our way back. Support for communist parties almost all over the world is growing, and capitalism is becoming more and more destructive both on nature and on society, so people will soon start looking for alternatives. And when they do, we'll be there!
 
Friday • 13-Sep-2002 • 5:36 am • # 2048 • 70-29S-SL
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 10:16 pm • # 2047 • 32-0U-HL
• US • • student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inother
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
I wish more genuine comrades would leave their e-mail adresses. I understand if you are afraid of infiltration, but certain risks are necessary if we are to succeed. Mine is slyFluenza @ hotmail.com Peace
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 8:50 pm • # 2046 • 91-11Y-PW
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 7:24 pm • # 2045 • 79-36F-ZW
Landis • Raleigh, USA • 15 • Student •
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 6:50 pm • # 2044 • 53-18Y-FI
Wes • Chicago, USA • 17 • None •
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 2:45 pm • # 2043 • 17-35X-UW
poll response:
••• Communism isother
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isother
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 2:21 pm • # 2042 • 64-8E-VW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inCuba
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Communist Manifesto this you socialist pigs
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 1:46 pm • # 2041 • 66-27R-GL
amanda hugnkiss • Winchestertofieldvil, North Korea • 57 • mistress •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
Why do you want to know my name anyway are you going to hunt me down and give me what for? Communism is a great idea in theory, however, it does not take into account one important factor, human nature. Do you really think that some day all the workers of the world will unite and come together to run everything as the proletariat? Not bloody likely. Now take your ruddy great poll and shove it in a none too comfortable place.
 
I hate communism and socialism.
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 1:14 pm • # 2040 • 7-63B-MW
John • Dallas, United States • 19 • Salesperson •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasother
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
Communism in essence is the enslavement of individualism and spirituality. Goverments who have adopted communism as their goverment quite quickly move tword socialism. I myself am a die hard conservative that believes in working for what you earn, in stead of helping others before helping yourself.
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 1:00 pm • # 2039 • 60-56O-HL
poll response:
••• Communism isnot sure
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
 
Screw You Commies
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 10:52 am • # 2038 • 11-52A-IW
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) innot sure
••• Genuine socialism isnot sure
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
Screw Communism. I'm an American. Communists suck
 
Communism = The futere
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 9:09 am • # 2037 • 25-59V-QY
Sam • Brasschaat (Antwerp), Belgium • 17 • army student • http://www.marine.nl
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
Commusim has excisted ans till does it is the future it only needs to evolve more in the future communism will be the sullusion to all problems war, desices, being poor. But fore this to work everybody needs to believe it and needs to work for it. i look forward to the time the new red world will come and i'll be there as first to help it Hold on comrads the future is communism
 
Communisn can work,only if we all unite.
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 8:33 am • # 2036 • 76-60A-VL
Simon • cork, Ireland • 18 • student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
We need to unite.People have misconceptions about communism ,we need to tell them the truth ,we need to show them sense and that it's for the good of every one,only then can we even think about having a new revoulution. if anyone would like to e mail me my address is : zarn @ 37.com. Feel free to email me as I do not use this site every often
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 1:37 am • # 2035 • 21-18L-ZW
Ben • Longmont, United States • 18 • Student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
Many people cofuse communism with The People's Republic of China or Stalin's failed and tyrannical rule. That's bull--bleep--. When you say you approve of communism, people think of the USSR, China, etc. It's just too bad that people don't understand it, and recognize the biases and wrongs that come with capitalism.
 
Communism
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 1:26 am • # 2034 • 1-23W-CB
jeremy • clovis, USA • 16 • Student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inSweden, other
••• Genuine socialism isnot sure
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
I believe that communism the form that Marx and Lenin created was what could save the world, the Soviet Union was a poor excuse for communsim and was nothing close to it.
 
Thursday • 12-Sep-2002 • 12:16 am • # 2033 • 0-32N-UL
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
 
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 4:57 pm • # 2032 • 41-34N-HH
will • hockwold, UK • 16 • Student •
poll response:
••• Communism isother
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
capitalism sucks
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 4:02 pm • # 2031 • 8-34N-SL
Gavin • Halifax, England • 15 • Profesional Communist •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
communism is the way forward but there are two types of bastard that stand in our way Fashists and capitalists
 
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 1:15 pm • # 2030 • 80-37O-BI
don • • • •
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inSweden
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 12:58 pm • # 2029 • 60-0H-FW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) innot sure
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
communism sucks
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 8:32 am • # 2028 • 23-1R-KL
steven • manchester, england • 16 • student • http://www.communismsucks.org
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inSweden
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 6:17 am • # 2027 • 19-9B-GO
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inother
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
manifesto
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 3:55 am • # 2026 • 50-32F-BC
corpse • seongnam, Korea • 20 • college student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
UNITE!!
 
Wednesday • 11-Sep-2002 • 3:22 am • # 2025 • 38-4U-CW
Darryl • Manila, Philippines • 16 • student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) innot sure
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
I am an ardent follower of the marxist views and i think communism is in the future of mankind.
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 11:40 pm • # 2024 • 59-27E-IW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) innot sure
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
 
Face Reality
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 10:16 pm • # 2023 • 21-31R-BW
Gene • Riverside, USA • 51 • Bookseller • http://www.abe.com/home/renbookshop
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
Every state that has called itself socialist has created a police state, based on slavery, suppression of alternative parties, arbitrary rule by a bureaucratic caste, and mass murder.

Why are people leaving Cuba instead of trying to get in? Why did people leave East Germany at risk of life?

 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 9:59 pm • # 2022 • 73-16O-CW
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 9:15 pm • # 2021 • 71-0X-AO
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 6:02 pm • # 2020 • 34-22N-BS
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
 
communism
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 10:05 am • # 2019 • 76-16Y-DW
Caeden • Florence, USA • 14 • student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
Communism will never exist until the rich democratic governments (usa) give up their brainwasing hold on scociety. Most kids will be taught that even the idea of communism is a horrible tyranicle form of slavery. Human nature also poses as a big factor in the non sucesfulism of communism. The leaders are all powerhungry tyrants but if pure people were found who just wanted a better scociety then whatever country praticed this form of government would quickly excell the others in all factors. Still one problem wold be that the country would have to survive independantly because no trade imbargo would be accepted by most countries because they would still want money. Also a classles scosiety would be the perfect way of eliminating crime and poverty. [to read more of my opinions read my full report on the T4 website]
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 5:10 am • # 2018 • 30-57I-EW
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, Sweden
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byother
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 1:14 am • # 2017 • 64-57L-GW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia, Sweden
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Tuesday • 10-Sep-2002 • 12:07 am • # 2016 • 13-52V-ZO
Bob • Adelaide, Australia • 16 • Rantificator •
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inCuba
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Monday • 9-Sep-2002 • 7:50 pm • # 2015 • 79-22Q-ZI
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Monday • 9-Sep-2002 • 4:06 am • # 2014 • 20-22A-SO
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 11:01 pm • # 2013 • 0-32N-KW
poll response:
••• Communism isother
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
 
Yes, Communism Can Work!
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 10:35 pm • # 2012 • 73-16O-OW
TroikaRed • -, - • - • Student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
We will get our revolution someday! Although I favor Communism with a little more control over the people (TOO MUCH freedom causes social ills like those seen in the USA today, but everyone should have JUST ENOUGH freedom), your items on democracy were interesting.
 
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 6:04 pm • # 2010 • 6-28W-ZW
poll response:
••• Communism isother
••• The Soviet Union wasother
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byother
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 3:40 pm • # 2009 • 59-21V-BW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 2:49 pm • # 2008 • 62-40C-ZW
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
My Thoughts
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 2:10 am • # 2007 • 25-23U-ZG
Matthew • Pahiatua, New Zealand • 15 • student • http://www.proctor.netfirms.com
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inChina, Cuba, Sweden
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
When I was young, I thought "This is what the world will be like... blah, blah blah", and then early this year, I rediscovered what I had been thinking in history. I, of my own accord, thought up communism. Of course my version was a lot crappier and less realistic, but that is not the point. So I decided to find out some more. I haven't read too much of your work yet, but I whole heartedly agree. By destroying controlled involuntary media, by the government or otherwise, you have deprived the bourgeousie of their main connection connection with the people; advertising. I am yet to read the self organising moneyless economy, but I'm looking forward to findig out more of your theories.
 
Sunday • 8-Sep-2002 • 1:48 am • # 2006 • 31-41Z-HO
poll response:
••• Communism isnot sure
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
 
Saturday • 7-Sep-2002 • 11:50 pm • # 2005 • 54-43P-CW
Jeff • Cleveland, USA • 17 • Service Clerk •
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) innot sure
••• Genuine socialism isnot sure
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
 
Saturday • 7-Sep-2002 • 11:03 pm • # 2004 • 59-42E-PW
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
 
Saturday • 7-Sep-2002 • 6:53 pm • # 2003 • 47-60I-BW
James • Folkenson, USA • 15 • Student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) informer Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, former Yugoslavia, other
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by a corrupt bureaucracy
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byother
••• The FAQI have read the FAQ
The fact that you are even allowed to say these things is profe that you are wrong. If there was any truth to what you said, you would have been silenced a long time ago.
 
Socialism is Fascism
Saturday • 7-Sep-2002 • 12:44 pm • # 2002 • 42-20K-SW
MaxB • USA • 46 • Computers • http://www.geocities.com/bananaticoco
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isa monstrous system of slavery
••• The Soviet Union wassocialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inCuba
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled byeverybody, in a democratic way
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
I like to deal in facts and not idealism or fantasies. For example, Right and Left are just terms we use against each other. Didn't you people know that Fascism is very much like Socialism. http://www.tfp.org/what_we_think/fascism.html The unconditioned, intelligent, open minded will see this. The biggest irony is for a Left winger to call somebody who doesn't agree with them a "Fascist". This is like "the pot calling the kettle black". MARXISM, SOCIALISM, AND FASCISM ARE JUST LETTERS BELONGING TO THE SAME COIN. But just like warring siblings, they tend to call each other names, and while their tactics might be slightly different,---THE END IS THE SAME--------DISASTER. Yes, one thing common to all Socialist states has been its inability to deliver what Socialism promises and redistributing poverty and famine. And, the Leftist inept and obtuse keep on revising and reclassifying themselves to justify the dismal failures of their Socialism in its many different forms. One tactic of liberals is to describe Western Europe as "Socialist". THIS IS INCORRECT. Western Europe is a mixture of Capitalism and some Socialism; it's a MIXED ECONOMY----and like any other country or system in this planet, not without their own problems. Western Europe is full of Corporations (http://www.europages.com/en/). So Western Europe can not be "Socialist". You see, Leftists don't have much of an argument on anything that's factual or based on reality, that's why everything to them has to be "relative". One of the tactics of the Socialist is to point out the imperfections of "Capitalis ... [read the rest of this lengthy post]
 
All work together
Saturday • 7-Sep-2002 • 10:29 am • # 2001 • 85-33W-KL
Rob • Salisbury, England • 17 • Student •
Vote for this post
poll response:
••• Communism isthe inevitable peaceful and abundant future of humankind
••• The Soviet Union wasan oppressive, exploitative, class-divided society that pretended to be socialist or communist
••• socialism exists (or existed) inhas never existed
••• Genuine socialism isthe rule of society by the working class
••• modern capitalist societies are ruled bythe rich (ie: the wealthy class, the bourgeoisie)
••• The FAQI don't need to read no stinkin' FAQ
if everyone... and i mean everyone, worked together to create a communist society, and everyone had the same power and rights... nobody is better or worse off than the next person, we would probably all be happier, and i believe that adopting a pure communist system will be the only way to solve many of the worlds most controversial problems. the basic reason past 'communist' reigiems have failed... i.e. Russia 1917, and later the USSR under the rule of Stalin, is because they were under rule. the theories that Stalin, Lenin and Marx preached were/are not what is practised. the leaders that believe they can rule a communist state need to do some research, cos a communist state is not something that can be ruled if it is to work. in russias communist attempts it was obvious that people were either better or worse of than other people. If we adopted a pure communist system at least everyone would be in the same boat. however... who would we have then to lead us, keep civil law, etc. i believe in communism, and i suppose u could call me a communist for my belief in the theory of it all, but i still realise that pure communism will fail through lack of a leading body of people.finally, surely we should not put a 'scientific definition' on communism or any other system of living, not class things and so on, because if we cannot achieve a state of the real definition of a system, then the definition is invalid, and not true.



To see previous responses, click here.


Workers' militia defending
the barricades--Paris, May 1871

Proletarian Democracy
How will economics, politics and culture work
when the working class runs modern society?
Working class rule has never existed except in embryonic form (the Paris Commune of 1871 and early Soviet Russia). Nevertheless it will emerge triumphant in the 21st century. How will a modern society suppress the former ruling bourgeoisie without also suppressing the independent political life of workers?
-- features bulletin board and email list --

The primary obstacle to the development of a mass movement focused on the overthrow of bourgeois rule and its replacement with a system of workers' rule is the complete theoretical bankruptcy of nearly all conceptions of workers' rule.
The proletarian democracy web site, bulletin board and email discussion lists are focused on helping to overcome this theoretical bankruptcy.
Topics discussed include: • competition of multiple workers' parties in the context of a stable, modern society • The theoretically degenerate "left ecosystem" that offers activists two equally stupid alternatives: (1) a "socialist" police state or (2) eternal bourgeois rule. • The sword of mass-based information war and the shield of separation of speech and property • The Transition Economy • Cargo Cult Leninism • Participatory Economics • the Self-Organizing Moneyless Economy

Interactivity for this site
by the Red Team


Information refineries
for the proletarian century