The Anarcho-Leninist
Debate on the State
Do you have ideas or do ideas have you?
The debate question • In the period immediately following
a successful mass uprising against the bourgeoisie,
should the form (or forms) of organization adopted by the proletariat
to secure its ultimate liberation be understood to be a state?

Part 4 • Daniel • November 11, 2002
An Anarchist Replies


part 3
READ
this part
RATE
this part
readers
comments
on this part

part 5

Home • The Action • Comments • Questions • Links

 
Please Note: if you are using Netscape or some other browser other than a recent version of Microsoft's Internet Explorer, then you may not be able to see the essay in the "floating frame" below. If this happens you can see it by clicking here.

 Rate (and comment on) Part 4
 -- all questions are optional --
polemical decency ?

Has Daniel exercized great care to fairly characterize Ben's positions and arguments?

Yes--Daniel has represented
      Ben's views fairly
      and accurately
No--Daniel has distorted
      Ben's views
not sure       other

non-evasive ?

Has Daniel answered all questions that Ben has asked?

Yes--Daniel answered all
      of Ben's questions
No--Daniel evaded some
      of Ben's questions

not sure
other

relevant ?

Are the points that Daniel raises
relevant to the debate question?

Yes--Daniel's points are
      relevant to the question
No--Daniel's points are
      irrelevant to the question
not sure       other

insightful ?

Has Daniel raised new, interesting, thoughtful or insightful points?

No--heard it all before
Yes--interesting and insightful

not sure
other

• One post per hour to forum # 114
• No threats   • No racist filth
first name (or pseudonym)
Your comments: (600 characters max, about 100 words)

 
Please Note: if you are using Netscape or some other browser other than a recent version of Microsoft's Internet Explorer, then you may not be able to see user's replies and poll results in the "floating frames" below. If this happens you can see these by clicking here and here.

comments on Part 4    
Is this window too small?
Want to make it bigger?
Click here

poll results for Part 4    
Is this window too small?
Want to make it bigger?
Click here


part 3
READ
this part
RATE
this part
readers
comments
on this part

part 5

Home • The Action • Comments • Questions • Links

Interactivity for this site
by the Red Team


Information refineries
for the proletarian century